Property
-
August 26, 2025
4th Circ. Revokes Class Cert. In Progressive Car Valuation Suit
The Fourth Circuit reversed a Progressive Insurance policyholder's class certification win over certain adjustments the insurer makes when calculating the actual cash value of a totaled vehicle, saying that determining whether Progressive breached each insured's policy is a "highly individualized assessment."
-
August 26, 2025
1st Circ. Says Insurer Owes No Defense In Eviction Suits
A Liberty Mutual unit has no duty to defend a commercial real estate loan provider in underlying suits over the eviction of residents from a Massachusetts senior care facility, the First Circuit ruled, finding the insurer's denial of coverage to be reasonable.
-
August 22, 2025
Investment Cos.' IRS Deal Not Covered, Liberty Unit Says
Two property investment companies aren't entitled to $1.7 million in coverage for a settlement reached with the IRS over a rejected $20.2 million charitable contribution deduction, a Liberty Mutual unit told a Georgia federal court, saying the deal was finalized without its knowledge or consent.
-
August 22, 2025
Supplement Co. Says Insurer Failed To Pay $2.1M Claim
The parent company of sports nutrition and supplement website Bodybuilding.com told an Idaho federal court that a Berkley unit failed to fully pay for property damage and business income loss after a water pipe burst at the Boise-based data center hosting the website's servers.
-
August 21, 2025
AI Tools Spark Debate Over Insurance Policy Interpretation
An artificial intelligence tool drafts an insurance policy and makes a note of potential inconsistencies in language.
-
August 21, 2025
Abuse Claim Influx Raises Insurance Woes For Calif. Schools
Legislation in California eliminated a number of claim prerequisites and the statute of limitations for childhood sexual assault survivors pursing litigation against public entities, but five years later insurance experts are sounding the alarm as to how this legislation has impacted public schools' ability to procure adequate liability coverage at a reasonable cost.
-
August 21, 2025
Q&A: Lawmaker Takes Aim At High Property Insurance Costs
Finding ways to make property insurance more affordable in New York is the intended outcome of a New York State Senate investigation into a crisis that's threatening to price people out of their communities, said the chair of the senate's insurance committee.
-
August 21, 2025
Why Del. Policyholders Should Heed CVS Opioid Claim Loss
The Delaware Supreme Court's refusal to reverse a lower court's ruling that CVS Corp. isn't owed coverage for government, hospital and third-party payer claims for economic losses related to the company's opioid dispensing practices marks a concerning turn for policyholders incorporated in the state, a policyholder attorney told Law360.
-
August 21, 2025
Insurance Litigation Week In Review
Units of Chubb and AIG don't owe coverage to CVS in suits over the opioid epidemic, BP and Chevron needn't reimburse a surety $11 million, a reinsurer must face investors' misrepresentation claims, and an Allianz insurer must pay $23 million in damages and interest in an asbestos coverage suit.
-
August 20, 2025
What To Watch In Florida Real Estate In 2025's Second Half
Florida real estate is less impervious to challenges confronting the industry and broader economy than in recent years, but local attorneys and real estate professionals say they expect the market will continue to attract people, business and investment in the second half of 2025 and beyond.
-
August 19, 2025
Manufacturing Cos. Score $23M Win In Lengthy Asbestos Suit
Two manufacturing companies involved in a long-running dispute over coverage for asbestos bodily injury claims have won $23 million from an Allianz unit for damages and interest, with a New York trial court finding the manufacturers properly determined claim liabilities.
-
August 18, 2025
Insurer, Kennel Settle Coverage Dispute Over Nuisance Claims
A Hanover unit and a dog kennel have resolved a dispute over coverage for an underlying suit alleging that the kennel's expansion interfered with a Golden State community's rights of possession, according to a California federal court filing.
-
August 18, 2025
Progressive Must Cover $6M Title Insurer Judgment, Mall Says
Progressive must cover a more than $6 million judgment against a title insurance agency that Progressive insured, the owner of a New Jersey shopping center told a Pennsylvania state court, arguing that Progressive-appointed counsel rejected prior settlement opportunities in bad faith.
-
August 18, 2025
Travelers Unit Doesn't Owe Coverage For Mich. Building Fire
A Travelers unit does not owe coverage for a 2023 building fire, a Michigan federal court ruled, finding that the property owner failed to install and maintain an automatic fire alarm system as required by the policy.
-
August 15, 2025
Smoke Shop Tells Panel It's Owed Defense Over Fatal Crash
A North Carolina smoke shop urged a state appeals court to find that its insurer must defend it in a lawsuit alleging that an individual who consumed nitrous oxide products from the shop caused a fatal auto collision, noting it has already disputed underlying allegations of negligence.
-
August 15, 2025
Insurer Says Towing Co. Not Covered In Car Hood Injury Suit
Prime Property and Casualty Insurance Inc. is suing a towing company in Florida federal court, saying it has no obligation to continue defending it in an injury suit stemming from injuries to a woman after one of the company's drivers helped jumpstart her car.
-
August 14, 2025
Ruling May Increase Reinsurers' Caution In Insureds' Dealings
A Texas federal judge's ruling that a chemical manufacturer can continue to pursue litigation against a reinsurer in connection with the manufacturer's roughly $100 million business interruption claim offered a well-reasoned analysis as to when a policyholder has standing to bring a direct action against a reinsurer, experts said.
-
August 14, 2025
Fla. Citizens Ruling Highlights Late Property Claim Risks
A recent Florida appellate court ruling affirming that the state's last-resort insurer properly denied a late-filed claim for hurricane damage wasn't surprising given legislative changes in recent years, but highlighted the import of filing timely claims, experts say.
-
August 14, 2025
NC Mortgage Lender Seeks Coverage For Fraud Claims
A mortgage lender said it is owed $540,000 from a title insurer after a borrower filed a complaint with the North Carolina Department of Justice about fraudulent activity related to his loan, telling a federal court the insurer shirked its obligations under the policy and related coverage documents.
-
August 14, 2025
Insurance Key To Mitigating Mortgage Risks From Flooding
The increase of flooding in areas outside mandatory flood insurance purchase zones is contributing to mortgage risks for underinsured homeowners following disasters, underscoring a need to find ways to ensure more people have flood coverage, experts say.
-
August 14, 2025
Fla. Condo, Insurer Settle Hurricane Damage Coverage Suit
An insurer and a Florida condominium association have settled a dispute over coverage for property damage caused by a September 2020 hurricane, according to a New York federal court filing.
-
August 14, 2025
Insurer Avoids Bad Faith Claims In $2M Vandalism Case
A California state court dismissed a property owner's claims that its insurer refused in bad faith to cover nearly $2 million in vandalism losses after its tenant, a cannabis cultivator, ended its lease, but found the owner's breach of contract claim can still proceed to trial.
-
August 14, 2025
Insurance Litigation Week In Review
Defense cost payments by 3M can't satisfy the self-insured retention of its subsidiary's insurance policies, a subcontractor's insurer must indemnify a property owner in a pending injury suit, an excess insurer owes $2 million for a car crash, and a gym chain may have coverage for losses stemming from COVID-19 shutdown orders. Here, Law360 takes a look at the past week's top insurance news.
-
August 14, 2025
Poetry In Motions: Wallace Stevens Wedded Art, Insurance
Wallace Stevens was an acclaimed modernist poet, but his parallel career as an insurance attorney isn't as widely discussed, according to attorney Daniel J. Kornstein, who has studied Stevens' life. To mark the 70th anniversary of Stevens' death, Law360 spoke with Kornstein about what insurance law may have meant to the poet.
-
August 11, 2025
Panel Says Public Health Order, Not COVID, Is An Occurrence
Governmental COVID-19 shutdown orders, and not the pandemic itself, are what constitute an "occurrence" under Life Time Fitness' commercial property policy with Zurich American Insurance Co., a Minnesota state appeals panel ruled Monday, specifically analyzing an "interruption by communicable disease" endorsement providing up to $1 million per occurrence.
Expert Analysis
-
Think Like A Lawyer: 1 Type Of Case Complexity Stands Out
In contrast to some cases that appear complex due to voluminous evidence or esoteric subject matter, a different kind of complexity involves tangled legal and factual questions, each with a range of possible outcomes, which require a “sliding scale” approach instead of syllogistic reasoning, says Luke Andrews at Poole Huffman.
-
What Insurers Need To Know About OFAC's Expanded FAQs
The Office of Foreign Assets Control's recently expanded insurance FAQs clarify how OFAC views insurance policies in a number of specific circumstances involving sanctioned parties, and make plain that sanctions compliance is the responsibility of all participants in the insurance ecosystem, including underwriters, brokers and agents, say attorneys at Morgan Lewis.
-
Nevada Justices Could Expand Scope Of Subrogation Claims
The Nevada Supreme Court's recent decision to hear North River Insurance v. James River Insurance could expand the scope of equitable subrogation claims in the state by aligning with the California standard, which doesn't require excess insurers to demonstrate damages, says Daniel Heidtke at Duane Morris.
-
A View Into NY's New Business Interruption Insurance Law
In response to businesses' economic challenges during the pandemic, New York recently allowed the issuance of stand-alone business interruption insurance coverage, and while pricing and insurer participation questions remain, the product stands to benefit business owners and the state economy, say attorneys at Saxe Doernberger.
-
California Supreme Court's Year In Review
Attorneys at Horvitz & Levy highlight notable decisions on major questions from the California Supreme Court's last term, including voter initiatives, hostile work environment and the economic loss rule.
-
8 Tech Tips For Stress-Free Remote Depositions
Court reporter Kelly D’Amico shares practical strategies for attorneys to conduct remote depositions with ease and troubleshoot any issues that arise, as it seems deposition-by-Zoom is here to stay after the pandemic.
-
Hurricane Coverage Ruling Clarifies Appraisal Scope In Fla.
In a case involving property insurance for hurricane damage, a Florida federal court recently enforced policy limits despite an appraisal award exceeding those limits, underscoring the boundaries between valuation and coverage — a distinction that provides valuable guidance for insurers handling post-catastrophe claims, says Tiffany Bustamante at Cozen O’Connor.
-
4 Ways Attorneys Can Emotionally Prepare For Trial
In the course of litigation, trial lawyers face a number of scenarios that can incite an emotional response, but formulating a mental game plan in advance of trial can help attorneys stay cool, calm and collected in the moment, says Rachel Lary at Lightfoot Franklin.
-
Presidential Campaign Errors Provide Lessons For Trial Attys
Vice President Kamala Harris’ presidential campaign employed numerous strategies that evidently didn’t land, and trial attorneys should take note, because voters and jurors are both decision-makers who are listening for how one’s case presentation would affect them personally, says Reuben Guttman at Guttman Buschner.
-
Notable Q3 Updates In Insurance Class Actions
Total loss valuation cases and labor depreciation cases dominated the past quarter of insurance class actions, with courts continuing to reject challenges to condition adjustments in the former, and a pro-insured trend persisting in the latter, say attorneys at BakerHostetler.
-
How Property Insurance Coverage Shrank After The Pandemic
Insurers litigating property claims are leveraging rulings that provided relief in the COVID-19 context to reverse the former majority rule on physical loss or damage in all contexts, say attorneys at Reed Smith.
-
Consider The Impact Of Election Stress On Potential Jurors
For at least the next few months, potential jurors may be working through anger and distrust stemming from the presidential election, and trial attorneys will need to assess whether those jurors are able to leave their political concerns at the door, says Ken Broda-Bahm at Persuasion Strategies.
-
NC Ruling Takes Practical Approach To Duty-To-Defend Costs
In Murphy-Brown v. Ace American Insurance, a case of first impression, the North Carolina Business Court adopted the commonsense rationale of many state courts in holding that policyholders' defense costs should be deemed presumtively reasonable when a insurer breaches its duty to defend, say attorneys at McGuireWoods.